In my past couple of posts, I've explored two common fallacies, identifying them by the terms philosophers use. In particular, I've identified the non sequitur and the red herring.
For today's post, I will identify another common fallacy--the straw man. I don't know about you, but, like the red herring, when I read the name of this fallacy, I get curious. First, I get curious about the content of the fallacy: What is the straw man fallacy? Then, I get curious about the terminology:
To answer my first question, I will refer to our old friend the late Robert J. Gula. In Nonsense, Gula gives the following definition "When you take something your opponent has said, exag-gerate [sic] or distort it, and then attack what you have exaggerated or distorted, you have created a straw man (79).
Although Gula doesn't mention it, I think my former logic professor described the straw man fallacy as a person building a scarecrow. A scarecrow is sort of like a man made of straw, and a man made of straw is, unlike a man made of muscle and bone, easily knocked down and destroyed. Of course, the man in "the straw man fallacy" is not actually a man; it's actually an argument.
But not just any argument.
It is the argument put forth by an opponent. Sometimes your opponent's argument might derive a conclusion that is very close to something that you already believe. Other times, however, your opponent's argument might derive a conclusion that is the opposite to something that you already believe.
Although we should always be on guard against all fallacious reasoning, it is the latter situation that we need to be extra mindful of maintaining our logical poise. The urge to build a straw man is more intense when we confront an argument with which we intensely disagree. Why?
Because there are certain beliefs of ours that we cherish; we don't want to admit that they lack the strength we attribute to them.
If someone makes an argument that weakens one of our cherished beliefs, we may respond by creating a straw man. Thus, when we engage, whether in speech or writing, in controversial topics, the temptation is usually greater that I will misrepresent my opponent's argument. I will change my opponent's argument into a much weaker argument and then attack that much weaker argument.
For example, take a look at the following dialogue:
Jack: "Who'd you vote for?
Jill: "Well, after listening to the debates I voted for candidate X. I really think that her argument about the environment was strong. It's about time a candidate for public office built her platform on key environmental concerns."
Jack: "Candidate X? Are you crazy? My father told me that she wants to ban the sale and purchase of sports cars and that she will enact a law requiring every household to go dark for three days a month. She thinks that we should all go back to living in log cabins and riding horses. I mean, there is no way. Given the lifestyle that most Americans have grown accustomed to living, her arguments are totally impractical. Voting for candidate X is stupid."
How does Jack's response to Jill seem?
It seems dubious to me. Probably, candidate X put forth a series of arguments that contained a series of conclusions that were much more nuanced than the ones he represents. He misrepresents candidate X's argument, which makes it much weaker. After he attacks the weakened argument, he draws his own fallacious conclusion. This is a very common fallacy. Politicians do it all the time. Mothers, fathers, sons, and daughters do it all the time as well.
Let's take another example:
[It's dinner time. BLT's are on the menu. A plate of bacon is sitting in the middle of the table.]
Mom: "Look at all that grease.We're not getting any younger. We eat a lot of meat. Our blood pressure and cholesterol levels are probably at dangerous levels. If we want to live longer, we need to eat healthier. We should modify our diet. We should eat more vegetarian meals."
Dad: "Don't be ridiculous. After a hard days work, I'm not gonna sit down and waste my time nibbling on rice cakes and lettuce. If that's what you want to eat, be my guest. I don't want to eat foods that have no taste. Besides, I need protein, I need vitamins and minerals. I need iron. You can't get iron from rice cakes."
So mom concludes that her and her husband should eat more vegetarian meals. Dad takes her conclusion and exaggerates it. After he exaggerates it, mom's argument is much weaker than it was when she articulated it.There may be good reasons to reject mom's argument, but dad hasn't provided any.
Because we cherish many of our beliefs, we don't want them to come under fire. When we are engaged in an episode of argumentation--whether through speech or writing--it is easier to misrepresent an opponent's argument, especially when the argument is strong, than it is to accurately present it. We need to fight this urge.
Straw men should be built to keep crows away, not the reasoned and fair challenges our opponents present to us.
This is a site for discussion about writing sponsored by the Writing Center and the Writing Across the Curriculum program at Eastern Illinois University.
Friday, November 30, 2012
Wednesday, November 28, 2012
Motivation and Biting the Bullet
I’m going to share a little secret with you, one
I am sure some if not most of you will empathize. From the time Halloween rolls around bringing pumpkins, football, crisper
weather, hot cider…and midterms on, I find it increasingly difficult to stay
motivated to do my work, to concentrate on the tasks at hand, and to do it all
with a smile on my face and a skip in my step.
The things I really want to be doing are going to
the movies or to the bookstore to get the latest book in a series I have been
waiting for (I know some of you might not love this idea, but roll with it). I
want to spend time with my family and friends without feeling guilty for
putting off this research or that paper for a little bit longer, or for turning
down those same people to do this research or that paper.
So, by the time Thanksgiving Break comes and goes, my mind
and body are shutting down, preparing for Winter Break and in a very
animalistic way hibernating for winter.
The question is: how do I (read: we for those who are
nodding their heads and giving me an “Amen!” as you read) keep going, stay
motivated (enough), and get what I need done, done?
In my eyes, there is only one answer: Bite the bullet.
Dig deep and find those last dregs of motivation and
determination to get the job done. Do it and put it aside. Then go celebrate a
job well done…or at least a job done to the best of your ability while juggling
all your other final projects.
Of course, getting myself to that point also takes a certain
amount of avoidance, brooding, and panic to light a fire under my tooshie.
But then I do it. I bite the bullet. I hand it in, and then
I take the time to relax over break (read: work and make some extra money for
the next semester, see family and friends, and generally run around like a
chicken with its head cut off, but in an entirely different way than I do while
I’m in school).
Tuesday, November 27, 2012
Writing an Essay is Engaging In Conversation
Now is the time of year when many students are wondering how they will turn a semester’s worth of knowledge and information into a term paper.
Collecting
relevant information and sorting out irrelevant information is hard enough, but
how does one write it all down? How does one go about dumping information from
brain to paper?
The first
lesson I learned when dealing with outside sources is that I needed them! And I
needed a lot of them!
The second
lesson I learned was that the bits of information I found, had to be correctly
cited.
The third
lesson I learned was that when I wanted to make any claim at all, it is better when I can find a source to back
me up.
This last
lesson I always had trouble with, and I believe many students do. Having to
support one’s claim through another author’s words seems a bit like having to
hold a stranger’s hand in order to be taken seriously. And seriously is how your professors want you
to take the assignment.
Lately,
within the last couple of years of writing essays, I have learned a new
approach to using sources and information effectively. Instead of trying to
find an authoritative voice (one that I will probably be unfamiliar with) to
back up my claims in an essay, I can simply engage in a conversation with other
educated voices.
Thinking of
an essay as engaging in a conversation is key!
Looking at
sources as requirements to prove a point verses using them as engaging in a
conversation may seem a bit like splitting hairs, but let me explain.
When a
student perceives their sources as experts that they must rely on to accomplish
a simple task in writing, it immediately diminishes their confidence as a
writer. The student is supposed to embrace the role of the expert on the
subject of the essay he or she is writing. At the same time he or she must ride
on the shoulders of several other "real" experts in order to make a
point, to get to the conclusion, and to get the grade. It doesn’t work. The
flow and tone of the paper is disrupted, disjointed, and convoluted.
Instead, if
a student views their sources as other sides of a conversation, then the essay
has a far better chance of succeeding. Not only will the information be there,
but the flow of the essay, the tone of the writer, and overall experience of
the essay will improve.
Engaging in
a conversation solves another problem with writing essays.
One of the
most common difficulties with writing essays is staying engaged and
focused. Using sources in a one person
conversation can feel like having a conversation with one’s own self on a
single topic for several hours. The experience can be tiresome and
exhausting. However, the focus of an
essay is more organic when the writer imagines the paper as a conversation. In
other words, it won’t sound like someone talking to themselves. This approach
also helps one consider the sources her or she wants to use, and how they might
use them. For example: an author with views and information closely aligned to
the main point of the essay becomes a friend used to engage in a collegiate
conversation. The author with an opposing view becomes an easy target.
As a student
views an essay as a conversation they are more likely to develop a provocative
perspective as well. No one engages in a conversation in order to echo a peer.
They engage in conversation because they have perspective no one has stated in
the conversation.
This
provocative perspective is the 'Gap' every essayist and professor wants to see
in an essay.
Friday, November 16, 2012
Have a Good Thanksgiving Break
We at the Writing Center hope faculty and students have a restful and enjoyable Thanksgiving break.
But we thought we'd share an image and some advice we got from the University of Alabama Writing Center's Facebook page.
We look forward to working with you over the final two weeks of the semester, but we strongly advise you to make your appointments ahead of time because our consulting schedule will fill up quickly these last couple of weeks.
Although it's possible you might be able to get walk-in appointments, it's not probable. So schedule ahead of time.
Drop by the Writing Center (3110 Coleman Hall) or give us a call (581-5929) to schedule appointments. We're open 9am-3 pm and 6-9 pm on M, Tu, W, & Th and 9am-1pm on Friday.
See you there.
But we thought we'd share an image and some advice we got from the University of Alabama Writing Center's Facebook page.
We look forward to working with you over the final two weeks of the semester, but we strongly advise you to make your appointments ahead of time because our consulting schedule will fill up quickly these last couple of weeks.
Although it's possible you might be able to get walk-in appointments, it's not probable. So schedule ahead of time.
Drop by the Writing Center (3110 Coleman Hall) or give us a call (581-5929) to schedule appointments. We're open 9am-3 pm and 6-9 pm on M, Tu, W, & Th and 9am-1pm on Friday.
See you there.
Logical Lingo II
One of the seemingly stranger logical terms a student may encounter when listening to a debate or reading a correspondence between two opposing partisans is red herring.
A quick check of the OED informs me that before it denoted an illogical relationship, red herring was part of a longer idiom derived from hunting. To draw a red herring across the track (or some similar verbal construction) meant that someone was using a smoked herring (which is a fish) to train hounds to follow a trail.
This earlier meaning does not contain any negative or fallacious connotations. However, as a logical term red herring is common fallacy that when employed will inhibit people from communicating about controversial topics without losing their cool.
Basically, a red herring is a big, bright, pink fish with a powerful odor. Although used initially to train hounds to follow a specific scent, the idiom associated with this process eventually came to mean something closer to its opposite.
To accuse a person making an argument of employing a red herring is to, in the broadest sense, accuse them of creating a diversion. Thus, instead of staying on course, instead of pursuing the topic at hand, by employing a red herring the speaker or the writer hopes to lead the audience away from the relevant trail.
After defining red herring, Robert J. Gula adds the following detail: "The red herring is invariably irrelevant and is often emotionally charged" (74).
It's the emotionally-charged aspect that makes this particular fallacy so insidious to group discussion. Once the topic of debate becomes obscure or unclear, the chances the discussion will be productive is nil. To illustrate the effectiveness, especially in group discussion, of the red herring let's look at the following extended dialogue.
Jack: "The problem that I have with him is the truck he bought. I mean, in this day and age, how can anyone justify purchasing a car or truck that doesn't at least get 30 miles per gallon. The environment is falling apart: the amount of arctic ice is shrinking which is causing the polar bears to die off, there are areas in the Gulf of Mexico the size of Massachusetts that cannot support any life--no fish, no plants, no amoebas, nothing. Dead zones they call them--now we got a new way to capture energy. An innovation called fracking which provides us with natural gas only at the expense of our ground water supply. I suppose no one is perfect, but I think that buying a car or truck is one decision in which a person should strongly consider the environmental impact of their purchase. It's not like there aren't beautiful and reliable cars and trucks that get 30 miles per gallon on the market.
Jill: "I think he would admit that there are beautiful and reliable cars and trucks that get 30 miles per gallon on the market, but he needs a truck for work that he can afford. The cost of a suitable work truck that gets 30 miles per gallon would cost him an extra fifteen thousand dollars."
Jack: "I guess some people are greedier than others. What's strange is that Mike is supposedly a Christian. Doesn't the Bible have a verse in it that prohibits greedy people from entering heaven?"
Jill: "That's not what the Bible says. Besides, the Bible verse I think your referring to may not have been intended literally."
Jack: "How do you know what the Bible writers intended? Maybe they intended every verse to be taken literally. I know when I write something very important, when I write something that I want people to understand clearly, I intend it to be taken literally."
Jill: "You've never written a metaphor or simile before? That's ridiculous. I know that you write song lyrics that have all sorts of figurative language in them."
Jack: "I haven't written song lyrics in like six months. But even if I have written song lyrics before that doesn't mean I use symbolic language all the time. I suppose you never use language literally? You're a lawyer for crying out loud."
Jill: "Exactly. In order to practice law, I needed to pass the bar. You think I took a stroll in Wrigleyville? Or that the judges brought in a Chubby Checker tape and the law students limboed our way into the profession?"
Jack: "Who's Chubby Checker?"
How does this dialogue look to you?
It seems all over the place, doesn't it?
It starts off focusing on the environment and whether an environmental concern, a vehicle's miles per gallon, should determine the vehicle a person purchases. This initial topic is abandoned when Jack uses a red herring in the second paragraph to respond to Jill's explanation. The composition of the Bible may be a fascinating topic to explore under the correct circumstances, but, in the above dialogue, Jack simply uses the Bible to divert the legitimate counter-claim that Jill makes.
Jack then introduces a second red herring into the discussion. Like biblical composition, biblical interpretation may be, under the proper circumstances, a fascinating topic to discuss, but in this dialogue, Jack simply uses it to complicate and divert Jill's focus.
Jill also uses a red herring. The issue that Jack brings up about his own employment of literal language is narrowly defined. Jill doesn't address the narrowness; rather, she broadens his meaning, and, in doing so, she complicates and diverts the direction of the dialogue.
This dialogue contains only two speakers, and it ends up sprawling into all kinds of complicated but unrelated topics. Also, I hope you get the sense of the emotional aspects creeping into each speaker's tone. Emotions are an important aspect of human judgment and human life, but appealing to emotion is not acceptable in logical reasoning. Anger, laughter, pity, sadness could each be appropriate mechanisms of persuasion, but they are not logical forms of persuasion.
The red herring can incite each one of these. And once an emotional incitement occurs, it is difficult to regain the civility and seriousness that was lost.
There are many nourishing items on the menu of logic. The red herring isn't one of them.
Thursday, November 15, 2012
Freewriting: Writing Your Way Off the Struggle Bus
Is your mind full of the various assignments, final papers,
projects, and exams quickly approaching? Are you attempting to start those
papers, but find yourself unable to concentrate on the task at hand without thinking
of the ten other things you also need to do?
I feel your pain. I have been suffering from the too-many-things-to-do-in-too-little-time
syndrome for the past couple weeks. I am pressed for time and pressed for
original ideas.
So how can we clear the clutter and get to the good stuff?
Freewrite!
Freewrite!
Freewriting is a great strategy for getting all your ideas
out on paper, even if some of those ideas are, “I wonder what I’m going to do
this weekend?” or “I have no ideas.”
Here is how I describe it sometimes to students who come
into the Writing Center – word vomit. Just get it all out and you will feel
better for it just like when you have a stomach ache and feel nauseous.
Sit down and write whatever comes into your mind, and when
you hit a road block in your mind, pick a phrase like “struggle bus” and write
it over and over until that thought is interrupted by another one.
Focused freewriting is a more specific type of freewriting. You have your topic, you sit down, and write on it or one side of your argument non-stop until you have nothing else to say about it. Then, do the same for the other side of the argument. (If you need a source to help you, follow the link for "Generating Ideas" for some strategies to get started.)
Focused freewriting is a more specific type of freewriting. You have your topic, you sit down, and write on it or one side of your argument non-stop until you have nothing else to say about it. Then, do the same for the other side of the argument. (If you need a source to help you, follow the link for "Generating Ideas" for some strategies to get started.)
Once all your thoughts and ideas are out on paper, you can read
through what you have and see what you can glean from your freewriting to use
in your paper.
Who knows? You just
might surprise yourself and kill two birds with one stone this way: you work on
your paper, and you might work through a nagging issue in your mind or at least
get it out of your mind long enough to concentrate on what you have to
accomplish.
Monday, November 12, 2012
Consider Audience When Using Sources
This morning as I perused online news, I stumbled on a story
from Fox News reporting that the creator and voice of Sesame Street’s character
Elmo is under investigation for child sex abuse. In this online report Fox News
provides a link to TMZ.com as the source for the story.
At this point I became skeptical. I began to question the creditability of the news report not only because I was unfamiliar with TMZ.com, but also because the name sounds unreliable.
I followed the link offered by Fox News to see what I could learn about TMZ.com. The website appears to be a gossip site, featuring a “Got a Tip” text box in the top left corner of the home page. Clearly, TMZ.com is asking its readers for gossip tips. I no longer believed the report.
At this point I became skeptical. I began to question the creditability of the news report not only because I was unfamiliar with TMZ.com, but also because the name sounds unreliable.
I followed the link offered by Fox News to see what I could learn about TMZ.com. The website appears to be a gossip site, featuring a “Got a Tip” text box in the top left corner of the home page. Clearly, TMZ.com is asking its readers for gossip tips. I no longer believed the report.
As it turns out, CNN and MSNBC are also reporting on the story.
So the scandal (as journalist say) may
have ‘legs’ after all.
But that isn’t the point.
The point is that because Fox News cited TMZ.com as its
source, I, the reader, doubted the information presented to me. Only after
careful consideration of other sources did I confirm that the story may be
credible (although low-brow).
When students write papers,they cannot presuppose that their
audience will take the time that I did with the Elmo story (especially since
embedded links aren’t possible in print form). Students must use credible sources
when writing. Not only do the sources need to be credible, but they must sound
creditable to the intended audience.
For example:
If a student were to write a serious paper exploring the
rate of anorexia and poor body image mentality on college campuses, using
a source like cheezeburger.com is a poor and insensitive idea even if the
information gathered was pertinent.
Or
If a student decided to write on the credibility of today’s
political leaders and cited bamboozled.org as a source of information, an
unintended response from a reader maybe laughter.
When gathering information, a student’s priority should not
be the easiest place to get it. Instead, one should consider these tips from
Purdue OWL.
Using these tips will undoubtedly improve the context and creditability of a paper. Fox News and other news outlets may benefit from Purdue’s advice as well."What type of sources does your audience value? If you are writing for a professional or academic audience, they may value peer-reviewed journals as the most credible sources of information. If you are writing for a group of residents in your hometown, they might be more comfortable with mainstream sources, such as Time or Newsweek. A younger audience may be more accepting of information found on the Internet than an older audience might be.”
Labels:
Audience,
For Students,
Purdue OWL,
Reputable Sources,
research,
Writing Process
Saturday, November 10, 2012
Logical Lingo I
For the next few weeks, I am going to blog about some different logical terms and phrases, including the non sequitur, the red herring, and the straw man. For this blog, I will specifically explore the non sequitur.
You probably noticed the italicized font. I know the suspense is killing you.
Non sequitur is Latin for "it does not follow," and it has a colloquial meaning and a logical meaning.
Colloquially, it can mean that a person suddenly changes the topic of discussion. For example, take the following dialogue between two old colleagues:
Pete: I'm can't understand why gas prices are so high. Did you watch the news this morning?
Kate: Yeah.
Pete: Do you hear anything about a storm forming in the Gulf of Mexico--maybe the big oil refineries are threatened?
Kate: Mike just texted me. He just won $10 on a scratch off ticket.
In this dialogue, Kate's final two statements could each be colloquially classified as a non sequitur. The question that Pete asked her is ignored. Instead, she provides him with irrelevant information.
The logical definition is a little different than its colloquial one. In its most general connotation, given its etymology, I suppose it could mean several different kinds of fallacies. Any fallacy that prevents the proper movement from premises to conclusion could be considered a non sequitur.
In Nonsense, our friendly guide, the late Robert J. Gula defines it a little more narrowly: He writes: "A non sequitur is a statement that claims to make a cause-and-effect relationship when, in fact, there is no logical connection between the premises and the conclusion" (56).
Although this piece of logical lingo may be new to you. I'm sure you've been subjected to the reasoning process that it condemns. For example, let's imagine the following argument:
Premise 1: If you want to be a great basketball player, you need to have a lot of stamina.
Premise 2: In order for you to have a lot of stamina, you need to do a lot of strenuous cardiovascular activity.
Premise 3: XYZ is a pair of basketball shoes that look cool with any dark basketball uniform.
Conclusion: XYZ will make you a better basketball player.
The conclusion above is, according to Gula's definition, a non sequitur. Premise 1 is true. Premise 2 also seems true. Let's suppose that premise 3 is also true. Does the conclusion follow (or "logically connect") from these three premises?
In other words, when you move from the beginning of the argument to the end of the argument, do the terms or concepts contained in the premises move to the conclusion in a logically acceptable manner?
Perhaps another example will help to show what I mean when I ask whether the conclusion follows from the premises. Let's take a look at the following argument:
Premise 1: If I miss the bus, then I will have to walk to school.
Premise 2: If I have to walk to school, then I will be all sweaty during my class.
Premise 3: If I am all sweaty during my class, then I will not be able to concentrate on my professor's lecture.
Premise 4: I missed the bus.
What conclusion follows from these four premises? Well, it follows from premise 4 and premise 1 that "I will have to walk to school." What follows from this? Look at premise 2.
When we look at premise 2, we know that "I will be sweaty during my class" follows from "my walking to school." What follows from this?
Our conclusion: "I will not be able to concentrate on my professor's lecture."
Now let's go back to the example with the basketball shoes. I guess it's possible that the conclusion is true, but its relationship to the premises is very loose, so loose, in fact, it is close to being irrelevant. Because it states a causal conclusion that does not logically follow from the premises, it is, if we use Gula's definition, a non sequitur.
When you write a paper that calls for you to make an argument, you should watch out for the non sequitur. It might help to look carefully at your conclusion. If you write a paper about vegetarianism and conclude that "eating meat causes obesity," be sure that your premises are specific enough to support the conclusion. If your premises are all about the cruelty that animals endure in order for people to eat meat, then your conclusion will be a non sequitur.
I'm sure you can imagine many instances where a speaker or a writer might use a non sequitur as a means to persuasion. What we need to remember is that given there fallacious character, an argument that employs a non sequitur should not earn our vote.
Looking at what I've written about non sequiturs it probably doesn't surprise you that they play a big role in comedy--both sketch comedy and the unscripted kind that takes place between you and friends. For example, take the following examples:
"Let's go get some lunch. I've got a taste for a pizza. What about you?"
"Do clowns get paid by the hour or are they salaried?"
"Vegetarians live longer than carnivores. Maybe you should stop eating meat."
"The Bears won last night. 28-13."
"Let's stop at that gas station up there, so I can get a lottery ticket. The jackpot is up to 300 million."
"Martin Scorsese's been married five times. That fifth time must've been awkward during the vow exchange."
All these short dialogues are, or at least attempt to be, comedic instances of non sequiturs. They may not be funny, but I hope they help you see the comedic potential of the non sequitur.
You probably noticed the italicized font. I know the suspense is killing you.
Non sequitur is Latin for "it does not follow," and it has a colloquial meaning and a logical meaning.
Colloquially, it can mean that a person suddenly changes the topic of discussion. For example, take the following dialogue between two old colleagues:
Pete: I'm can't understand why gas prices are so high. Did you watch the news this morning?
Kate: Yeah.
Pete: Do you hear anything about a storm forming in the Gulf of Mexico--maybe the big oil refineries are threatened?
Kate: Mike just texted me. He just won $10 on a scratch off ticket.
In this dialogue, Kate's final two statements could each be colloquially classified as a non sequitur. The question that Pete asked her is ignored. Instead, she provides him with irrelevant information.
The logical definition is a little different than its colloquial one. In its most general connotation, given its etymology, I suppose it could mean several different kinds of fallacies. Any fallacy that prevents the proper movement from premises to conclusion could be considered a non sequitur.
In Nonsense, our friendly guide, the late Robert J. Gula defines it a little more narrowly: He writes: "A non sequitur is a statement that claims to make a cause-and-effect relationship when, in fact, there is no logical connection between the premises and the conclusion" (56).
Although this piece of logical lingo may be new to you. I'm sure you've been subjected to the reasoning process that it condemns. For example, let's imagine the following argument:
Premise 1: If you want to be a great basketball player, you need to have a lot of stamina.
Premise 2: In order for you to have a lot of stamina, you need to do a lot of strenuous cardiovascular activity.
Premise 3: XYZ is a pair of basketball shoes that look cool with any dark basketball uniform.
Conclusion: XYZ will make you a better basketball player.
The conclusion above is, according to Gula's definition, a non sequitur. Premise 1 is true. Premise 2 also seems true. Let's suppose that premise 3 is also true. Does the conclusion follow (or "logically connect") from these three premises?
In other words, when you move from the beginning of the argument to the end of the argument, do the terms or concepts contained in the premises move to the conclusion in a logically acceptable manner?
Perhaps another example will help to show what I mean when I ask whether the conclusion follows from the premises. Let's take a look at the following argument:
Premise 1: If I miss the bus, then I will have to walk to school.
Premise 2: If I have to walk to school, then I will be all sweaty during my class.
Premise 3: If I am all sweaty during my class, then I will not be able to concentrate on my professor's lecture.
Premise 4: I missed the bus.
What conclusion follows from these four premises? Well, it follows from premise 4 and premise 1 that "I will have to walk to school." What follows from this? Look at premise 2.
When we look at premise 2, we know that "I will be sweaty during my class" follows from "my walking to school." What follows from this?
Our conclusion: "I will not be able to concentrate on my professor's lecture."
Now let's go back to the example with the basketball shoes. I guess it's possible that the conclusion is true, but its relationship to the premises is very loose, so loose, in fact, it is close to being irrelevant. Because it states a causal conclusion that does not logically follow from the premises, it is, if we use Gula's definition, a non sequitur.
When you write a paper that calls for you to make an argument, you should watch out for the non sequitur. It might help to look carefully at your conclusion. If you write a paper about vegetarianism and conclude that "eating meat causes obesity," be sure that your premises are specific enough to support the conclusion. If your premises are all about the cruelty that animals endure in order for people to eat meat, then your conclusion will be a non sequitur.
I'm sure you can imagine many instances where a speaker or a writer might use a non sequitur as a means to persuasion. What we need to remember is that given there fallacious character, an argument that employs a non sequitur should not earn our vote.
Looking at what I've written about non sequiturs it probably doesn't surprise you that they play a big role in comedy--both sketch comedy and the unscripted kind that takes place between you and friends. For example, take the following examples:
"Let's go get some lunch. I've got a taste for a pizza. What about you?"
"Do clowns get paid by the hour or are they salaried?"
"Vegetarians live longer than carnivores. Maybe you should stop eating meat."
"The Bears won last night. 28-13."
"Let's stop at that gas station up there, so I can get a lottery ticket. The jackpot is up to 300 million."
"Martin Scorsese's been married five times. That fifth time must've been awkward during the vow exchange."
All these short dialogues are, or at least attempt to be, comedic instances of non sequiturs. They may not be funny, but I hope they help you see the comedic potential of the non sequitur.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
